The Game Census

Rating gap

Games whose scores across stores and aggregators sit furthest apart, on one 0–100 scale.

Of 13,916 games with at least 500 Steam reviews, 5,062 also carry two or more scores from other sources — OpenCritic, IGDB critics, IGDB users, the PlayStation Store and GOG. Each score is converted to 0–100 and the gap is the highest score minus the lowest, with Steam's positive-review percentage counted as one of the scores. The median gap across those 5,062 games is 16.4 points; the widest is 75.

The widest gap belongs to Quake II RTX: Steam 87 against IGDB users 12, a gap of 75 points across 3 scores, with 4,793 Steam reviews behind its 87% positive share. Among the 2,588 compared games that have an IGDB critic score, that score is higher than the Steam positive percentage in 614 of them (23.7%).

Coverage among the compared games: IGDB users 4,462, IGDB critics 2,588, PlayStation Store 3,360, OpenCritic 3,290, GOG 2,061. The table lists the top 100 by gap.

5,062
games compared
16.4 pts
median gap
75 pts
widest gap
23.7%
IGDB critics above Steam %
GameSteam %OpenCriticIGDB criticsIGDB usersPlayStationGOGGap
Quake II RTX87——12—7275
Fishing Planet86.8——2575—61.8
Capitalism 282.8——21—8261.8
Overwatch®32.2908369——57.8
My Friend Peppa Pig87.678—3072.2—57.6
MOBILE SUIT GUNDAM BATTLE OPERATION 222.2——7771.6—54.8
Garten of Banban 267.6——3386.2—53.2
7 Days to Die86.939366989—53
Super Seducer : How to Talk to Girls82.8—3056——52.8
POSTAL 4: No Regerts65.127—6879.4—52.4
Kitty Powers' Matchmaker96.3706962874452.3
Alien Hominid Invasion88.780—4395—52
Atari 50: The Anniversary Celebration92.486838084.44250.4
The Plan92.3—4258——50.3
Plantera88.7—3952——49.7
Hello Neighbor86.442374680.4—49.4
Call of Duty®: Warzone™30.880—67——49.2
Iron Snout97.7——4973.8—48.7
SLUDGE LIFE 296.771—48——48.7
Hello Neighbor 281.354—3378.6—48.3
Pesterquest89.7——7292.24448.2
SUMMERHOUSE93.170—4579.4—48.1
ONE PUNCH MAN: A HERO NOBODY KNOWS51.858533077.6—47.6
Project Warlock86.977804390.28047.2
Aquarist8351——35.8—47.2
Unknown 9: Awakening37.562642368.8—45.8
Garten of Banban54.3——3681.2—45.2
Ben 107554—3176—45
Easy Delivery Co.94.978—5091.68644.9
Potion Permit79.171703983.86444.8
Blood: Refreshed Supply™7384——96.85244.8
Blades of Time78.6346164—7244.6
Little Witch Academia: Chamber of Time76.959468090.6—44.6
Hatred84.5404349——44.5
BALAN WONDERWORLD53.648572771—44
FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY'S: HELP WANTED95.752—8089.6—43.7
Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell Double Agent®35.3—7976——43.7
Predator: Hunting Grounds7658673780.6—43.6
Fairy Fencer F Advent Dark Force84.9—684891.68243.6
Clustertruck93.5747469765043.5
Vampire: The Masquerade - Shadows of New York76.363—3375.86443.3
2Dark78.363594083.2—43.2
Sam & Max: Beyond Time and Space99.1—838093.25643.1
THE QUIET MAN™37.929311255—43
DreadOut76.8——34—6242.8
METAL GEAR SURVIVE65.760603072.6—42.6
Farming Simulator 1592.557507188.2—42.5
Calico86.5—446584.86042.5
YIIK: A Postmodern RPG78.560633677.6—42.5
SENRAN KAGURA Reflexions85.5434744——42.5
Danganronpa S: Ultimate Summer Camp62——4082.4—42.4
Dungreed93.3——5190.2—42.3
Total War: ROME REMASTERED77.174—35——42.1
Steel Division: Normandy 4474.5838543——42
Airships: Conquer the Skies95.9——54—8041.9
Cabernet94.881—5391.28641.8
Puyo Puyo Champions79.477724384.8—41.8
House Party85.7——44—6841.7
I Love You, Colonel Sanders! A Finger Lickin’ Good Dating Simulator91.750—50——41.7
Machinika: Museum92.7——51—8241.7
BlazBlue Entropy Effect94.384—53——41.3
Gal*Gun 28358535694.2—41.2
City of Brass77.869684081.2—41.2
Dungeon Munchies97.156—7588.2—41.1
Sakura Swim Club84.7——4888.8—40.8
Underworld Ascendant34.73121—61.8—40.8
Terminator: Resistance91.6585170—8640.6
Knock-knock87.2—475186.27840.2
MY LITTLE PONY: A Maretime Bay Adventure80.1——4079.4—40.1
Spirittea8476—44——40
Travellin Cats in Paris98.9——59—8639.9
Summer in Mara74.862624180.86639.8
Dustborn6666634275.83639.8
Amnesia™: Memories92.774—53—7839.7
Imagine Earth81.680—4280.67439.6
Hatoful Boyfriend: Holiday Star93.55654———39.5
ONE PIECE World Seeker76.960674685.4—39.4
Disneyland Adventures90.4656851——39.4
Sunrider: Mask of Arcadius92.3——53—7439.3
Monster Hunter Wilds5089878582—39
Goat Simulator90.960525481.8—38.9
Umbrella Corps31.736404070.6—38.9
Pit People®92.8807754——38.8
King of Retail87.6——49—6838.6
Ring of Pain91.474—53—8638.4
Milo and the Magpies98.4——60—9038.4
Sam & Max Save the World94.3—837894.25638.3
World of Tanks: HEAT46.875—8567.2—38.2
SpellForce: Conquest of Eo80.377—4381.2—38.2
Cats and Seek: Osaka98.2——6075.4—38.2
Please, Touch The Artwork 29976—61——38
Bunny Park9059——52—38
Tennis World Tour41.839327059.4—38
POSTAL 296.9—5972—8437.9
New Tales from the Borderlands31.167696460.4—37.9
STAR WARS™: Battlefront Classic Collection24.459605762.2—37.8
Yet Another Zombie Defense HD81.844——77.4—37.8
Sherlock Holmes and The Hound of The Baskervilles88.8——51—7637.8
Acting Lessons95.7——58—8237.7
Slipstream88.2——5289.67437.6

How each score is put on 0–100. Steam %: positive reviews divided by all Steam reviews, times 100. OpenCritic: the top-critic average, already 0–100. IGDB critics: IGDB's aggregated critic rating, already 0–100. IGDB users: IGDB's user rating, already 0–100. PlayStation: the PlayStation Store average star rating (0–5) multiplied by 20. GOG: the GOG catalog API review rating (0–50, stars times ten) multiplied by 2. A score is counted only with enough reviews behind it: at least 3 for OpenCritic, 3 for IGDB critics, 5 for IGDB users, 20 for the PlayStation Store and 20 for GOG. A dash means the source has no score for that game or too few reviews behind it. Scores outside a source's own range are left out rather than adjusted. Only games with at least 500 Steam reviews and two or more non-Steam scores are listed; scores are rounded to one decimal before the gap is taken. Sources: Steam, OpenCritic, IGDB, the PlayStation Store and the GOG catalog API. See the methodology for how the census collects these.